Trade Would you give up Scoot and Sharpe for Embiid?

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in

Would you trade Scoot and Sharpe (and others not including Dame) for Embiid?

  • Hell yes - finally Dame gets to contend

    Votes: 6 15.0%

  • Hell no - I'm not mortgaging the future for that loser

    Votes: 34 85.0%
  • Total voters
    40
Scoot and Ant -- MAYBE but not Sharpe -- Joel is a tad older then let's say if the Blazers went all in on Giannis plus he has been a tad minor injury prone too.
 
Sharpe might be the most talented player on the team one day, but he’s probably never going to be the vocal leader of the team. Scoot can be that guy, and will also have the game to back it up. He is as untouchable as Sharpe.
 
Embiid next year, estimated, $47.6 million
Scoot and Sharpe at around $16 million combined

Nurkic at a bit under $17 million
Simons a bit over $24 million

If the question is whether someone would trade Scoot and Sharpe for any one player in the NBA (ignoring the CBA), the answer would be yes. Scoot is unproven. Sharpe may max out at all star or above. May. Embiid is the MVP.

A more practical question would be trading Nurkic + Ant + Scoot for Embiid?
Dame, Sharpe, Nas/Matisse, Grant, Embiid and the current bench? Yes. And then improve the bench.
 
Not for Embiid.

I’d do it for Giannis. Id do it for Jokic. I would have done it for Durant or LeBron back in the day. But Embiid is too old and too injury prone. The risk is too high.
 
Yeah I think it would probably require both of Scoot/Sharpe. I'm super worried of Embiid injury risk. Yeah the Dame Embiid duo would be amazing, but we've seen many duos fail and this could really destroy the Blazers next decade of their future. The other problem is the Blazers also have to match salary.

Even if we waited 30 days so Scoot $10 million salary could be included him, Sharpe, Nurkic, Little, Keon is only $32 million. Embiid is $47.6 million. I guess if we could send Cam out somewhere in a sign and trade it would be possible.

The other contract we can send out is Ant, but then its all of Ant, Sharpe, Scoot being sent out. We have no starter at SG or at SF.

Dame
Thybulle?
Kris?
Grant
Embiid

That doesn't look close to a contending roster, even though the Dame/Embiid pairing is great.

If there was a way to send out all our future picks and also get Bridges or some type of elite wing in a mega trade it could make sense. That type of Dame/Bridges/Grant/Embiid group could contend even with a bunch of scrubs.

But otherwise I think as crazy as it sounds we might have to pass on Embiid. One of Scoot or Sharpe and I do it. But sending out both plus the Blazers not having pieces to have the roster contend immediately is too big of a risk.
 
HoopsFanAZ said:
Embiid next year, estimated, $47.6 million
Scoot and Sharpe at around $16 million combined

Nurkic at a bit under $17 million
Simons a bit over $24 million

If the question is whether someone would trade Scoot and Sharpe for any one player in the NBA (ignoring the CBA), the answer would be yes. Scoot is unproven. Sharpe may max out at all star or above. May. Embiid is the MVP.

A more practical question would be trading Nurkic + Ant + Scoot for Embiid?
Dame, Sharpe, Nas/Matisse, Grant, Embiid and the current bench? Yes. And then improve the bench.
Click to expand...

Yes the Blazers should pull the trigger on your bolded question. If its one of Scoot or Sharpe I make the deal. But I don't think thats enough for Philly. Giving up both doesn't leave the Blazers with enough to contend. Its an odd situations where a trade just doesnt make sense for either party.
 
Dame + Scoot on the Blazers or Dame + Sharpe? One or the other. Not a tough answer IMHO: Dame + Sharpe.
Dame + Scoot + Ant + Sharpe … means someone is getting traded … Ant or Dame (or Ant + Scoot).
 
I voted yes just so I could see the results of the poll

I wouldn't make the trade though
 
HoopsFanAZ said:
Dame + Scoot on the Blazers or Dame + Sharpe? One or the other. Not a tough answer IMHO: Dame + Sharpe.
Dame + Scoot + Ant + Sharpe … means someone is getting traded … Ant or Dame (or Ant + Scoot).
Click to expand...
I still don’t see Dame and Scoot work out together long term. Scoot is too good to just come off the bench.
 
Scoot and Simons probably.
 
Rastapopoulos said:
Um, for somebody who stalks me so much you really don't know what I think, do you
Click to expand...
I think this is the craziest suggestion you’ve made since your Papanikolaou fondness(maybe crazier), and I still remember you giving me a hard time for making a pap-smear joke.

Sharpe is legit… Do you think he’s really a sell high candidate? Like his value will never be higher than now?
 
illmatic99 said:
Are people falling in love with Scoot?

If someone proposed Shaedon plus the third pick plus Nurk and salary fillers, would people still say no?
Click to expand...

Yes Blazer fans are loving Scoot. There was much more appetite to trade the #3 pick before the draft then to now trade Scoot after fans have gotten to know him. Dude looks like a #1 pick type of franchise changing prospect. Sharpe is probably thought of even higher.

I'd consider the trade if there was a path to get that roster contending after the trade. I just don't see how a wing rotation starting with Thybulle and Murray would get the Blazers there, even with two great all stars. We've seen more of the great all star duos in the NBA fail than succeed. The other starters and role players are critical for those teams.
 
They can have Scoot + Ant + anything else on the roster except Dame + Sharpe.
 
An MVP or the potential of two young guys?

Pretty obvious what most Blazer fans will pick!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top