2008 GM Draft 1 Peer Evaluation Thread

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in
I want to play a up tempo style, thats why. I don't have a pg that can dish really well.
 
Thoughts on my team now that I've gotten a roster with a starting lineup and full backups.

With my backups I wanted to go with youth with my one exception being Nocioni, as he is older.

PG: Jason Terry/Javaris Crittenton
SG: Kyle Korver/Aaron Afflalo
SF: Rashard Lewis/Andres Nocioni
PF: Carlos Boozer/Sean Williams
C: Marcus Camby/Robin Lopez
 
DynastYWarrioR6 said:
Thoughts on my team now that I've gotten a roster with a starting lineup and full backups.

With my backups I wanted to go with youth with my one exception being Nocioni, as he is older.

PG: Jason Terry/Javaris Crittenton
SG: Kyle Korver/Aaron Afflalo
SF: Rashard Lewis/Andres Nocioni
PF: Carlos Boozer/Sean Williams
C: Marcus Camby/Robin Lopez
Click to expand...


I like how you have backups who hustle and play D in Lopez/Afflalo/Nocioni.

It'll be a nice change off the bench, as your starters' defense is below average.
 
DynastYWarrioR6 said:
Thoughts on my team now that I've gotten a roster with a starting lineup and full backups.

With my backups I wanted to go with youth with my one exception being Nocioni, as he is older.

PG: Jason Terry/Javaris Crittenton
SG: Kyle Korver/Aaron Afflalo
SF: Rashard Lewis/Andres Nocioni
PF: Carlos Boozer/Sean Williams
C: Marcus Camby/Robin Lopez
Click to expand...

Not a big fan of your starters defense or the fact that Jason Terry is your PG.

Other than that, I like your big man rotation.
 
Jason Terry wasnt my ideal image of a PG, as the PG i wanted was drafted like...right before I picked, and that was Devin Harris. Then when I did draft Terry, I decided to have him as my SG, but then my next couple picks for PG where selected, then I got bummed. But to make up for all that, I decided to keep Noc on the bench as he will be great off the bench. Then my bench I wanted a bunch of young, talented, and energetic players, therefore Afflalo, Critt, Lopez, and Williams.

I like Lopez and Williams for defensive purposes as well as rebounding and hustle. Afflalo is there also for defensive, plus he is good enough for me offensively off the bench as well. JCritt is a young player with a lot of offensive talent, and I like him.

I'll keep this up with my next picks.
 
Looking at your bench, your front court is a bit of an unknown with Sean and Robin. I agree with KC in that you've got a lot of hustle and D, but besides Nocioni I think you're really lacking shooting/scoring off the bench.
 
ok now my roster is:

PG: Baron Davis / Ronnie Price (pargo went overseas sorry)
SG: Ben Gordon / Mickael Pietrus
SF: Luke Walton / Joe Alexander
PF: David West / Yi Jianlian
C : Brendan Haywood

pretty solid to me... thoughts?!?!
 
Last edited:
GMJigga said:
Looking at your bench, your front court is a bit of an unknown with Sean and Robin. I agree with KC in that you've got a lot of hustle and D, but besides Nocioni I think you're really lacking shooting/scoring off the bench.
Click to expand...

I agree with you and I think the unknown can be tagged on the entire bench besides Nocioni seeing as how we haven't see much of them or any at all yet to judge them, but I just wanted to go with youth and potential with my bench besides Nocioni and I think I've accomplished that :D

Thanks for all the feedback guys.

(And maybe I just like being mysterious, maybe in a sexy way?)
 
danxcr said:
ok now my roster is:

PG: Baron Davis / Ronnie Price (pargo went overseas sorry)
SG: Ben Gordon / Mickael Pietrus
SF: Luke Walton / Joe Alexander
PF: David West / Yi Jianlian
C : Brendan Haywood

pretty solid to me... thoughts?!?!
Click to expand...

I'll get to your roster after my girlfriend leaves so just hang on :D
 
Team 1:
PG: D.Harris/Lowry
SG: K.Azubuike/M.Carrol
SF: R.Gay/C.J.Miles
PF: A.Horford/J.Maxiell
C: D.Milicic/R.Turiaf

I'm still going to try tweak with the starting unit, specifically at the center position. The only true center I have is Darko but I'm not sure who to star between him and Turiaf.
 
danxcr said:
ok now my roster is:

PG: Baron Davis / Ronnie Price (pargo went overseas sorry)
SG: Ben Gordon / Mickael Pietrus
SF: Luke Walton / Joe Alexander
PF: David West / Yi Jianlian
C : Brendan Haywood

pretty solid to me... thoughts?!?!
Click to expand...

I like Baron playing with David, that seems like it would be lots of fun. Then you have the luxury of Yi and Mickael coming off your bench. But Luke Walton starting for you is a liability on both ends of the floor. Yes, he can pass, but other than that, he won't really do any scoring for you. Plus on defense, he gets lost. The thing about Ben Gordon, is that he's a sreaky shooter, so on a bad night you can be screwed. Brendan Haywood is a legit starting center for you.
 
I need input on my roster because I won't be her next week. I would like to hear what u guys say about it now
 
kk30 said:
I need input on my roster because I won't be her next week. I would like to hear what u guys say about it now
Click to expand...

Well I don't like Tim Thomas, granted that's just personal bias. But I do feel he should be your backup SF and get a real rebounding banger as yoru backup to Amare. You have youth in your backups in Telfair and McCants. Your center position is your weakest position, but suitable. Get a backup PF that can really bang and rebound.
 
Last edited:
DynastYWarrioR6 said:
Well I don't like Tim Thomas, granted that's just personal bias. But I do feel he should be your backup SF and get a real rebounding banger as yoru backup to Amare. You have youth in your backups in Telfair and McCants. Your center position is your weakest position, but suitable. Get a backup PF that can really bang and rebound.
Click to expand...

Thomas is just an average defender and rebounder, offensively hes a good catch and shoot guy, he passes well for his size and is a good ball handler for his size. He can really spread the floor coming off the bench though. Yes he has his flaws such as disappearing at times but keep in mind hes just my bench player coming off the bench unlike the way the the clippers started him every game at PF. He may not be a banger but he provides versatility on offense. Honestly he will probably put up the same stats as Charlie V, Al Harrington and Yi and we went a couple of rounds later. He is just as good defensively as those 3 also. Also theres no banger left to draft

Hes a veteran and given 20 mins he can probably do 10pts and 4 rebs.

I don't know how you can say Haywood is a legit center and foster is not.
Foster is a legit center in my mind and can do well on any team /situation. He just does his job.
 
I never said Foster wasn't. I just said your weakest position is your center position, and I'm looking at both the starter and the backup. Just because I failed to mention him doesn't mean I hate the dude. But from PG to C, the Center position is your weakest.
 
DynastYWarrioR6 said:
I never said Foster wasn't. I just said your weakest position is your center position, and I'm looking at both the starter and the backup. Just because I failed to mention him doesn't mean I hate the dude. But from PG to C, the Center position is your weakest.
Click to expand...

ok my bad i misinterpreted what you meant.

Do you think my team is one of the better/middle/worse teams in the league.
 
DynastYWarrioR6 said:
I like Baron playing with David, that seems like it would be lots of fun. Then you have the luxury of Yi and Mickael coming off your bench. But Luke Walton starting for you is a liability on both ends of the floor. Yes, he can pass, but other than that, he won't really do any scoring for you. Plus on defense, he gets lost. The thing about Ben Gordon, is that he's a sreaky shooter, so on a bad night you can be screwed. Brendan Haywood is a legit starting center for you.
Click to expand...

THANK YOU SIR :) hehe now i have

PG: Baron Davis / Ronnie Price
SG: Ben Gordon / Mickael Pietrus
SF: Luke Walton / Joe Alexander
PF: David West / Yi Jianlian
C : Brendan Haywood / Marreese Speights

and to respond to ur luke walton thing... joe alexander can come off the bench and just provide defense... i think we all know how freakish his athletic ability is... and with ben gordon being streaky... he did avg almost 19 ppg in the struggling bulls.

but thank you for ur critique :) very well appreciated sir :)
 
Just because Alexander is athletic doesn't make him good at defense. That's his concern right now.
 
Thoughts?

PG: TJ Ford/ Chris Duhon
SG: Ray Allen/ Wally Szczerbiak
SF: Francisco Garcia/ Desmond Mason
PF: Emeka Okafor/ Brandan Wright
C: Tim Duncan
 
Jameer Nelson \ Charlie Bell
Deshawn Stevenson \ Keith Bogans
Joe Johnson \ Damien Wilkins
Drew Gooden \ Donte Greene (I know, he's too small, don't care)
Dwight Howard
 
pegs said:
Jameer Nelson \ Charlie Bell
Deshawn Stevenson \ Keith Bogans
Joe Johnson \ Damien Wilkins
Drew Gooden \ Donte Greene (I know, he's too small, don't care)
Dwight Howard
Click to expand...


Joe Johnson will get destroyed defensively as your SF. Donte green is a marvin williams type player and cant play PF. Deshawn stevenson?? Really? eh. The only player that looks good in my opinion is superman.
 
JFizzleRaider said:
Thoughts?

PG: TJ Ford/ Chris Duhon
SG: Ray Allen/ Wally Szczerbiak
SF: Francisco Garcia/ Desmond Mason
PF: Emeka Okafor/ Brandan Wright
C: Tim Duncan
Click to expand...


Really nice team. Tj Ford's health has to be a concern & I know Garcia is a good player... but is he a starter? SPECIALLY at small foward? Isnt he a Shooting guard?
 
DynastYWarrioR6 said:
Thoughts on my team now that I've gotten a roster with a starting lineup and full backups.

With my backups I wanted to go with youth with my one exception being Nocioni, as he is older.

PG: Jason Terry/Javaris Crittenton
SG: Kyle Korver/Aaron Afflalo
SF: Rashard Lewis/Andres Nocioni
PF: Carlos Boozer/Sean Williams
C: Marcus Camby/Robin Lopez
Click to expand...



I dont like Terry as your starting PG. I believe Korver can have a bigger impact off the bench. I dont know how good Affalo is & You got to hope for Swat to not foul in every play. Also Lopez is an unknown but that could turn out to be a good thing.
 
Claud said:
Joe Johnson will get destroyed defensively as your SF. Donte green is a marvin williams type player and cant play PF. Deshawn stevenson?? Really? eh. The only player that looks good in my opinion is superman.
Click to expand...
Just like he got destroyed on the Suns, being their best defender, right?

Oh, and Marvin Williams did play the 4 some
 
Claud said:
Really nice team. Tj Ford's health has to be a concern & I know Garcia is a good player... but is he a starter? SPECIALLY at small foward? Isnt he a Shooting guard?
Click to expand...

Garcia can play either SG or SF. The Kings use him mainly at the 3. There's nothing wrong with him playing SF, aside from the fact that he's skinny as hell.
 
I don't think Joe Johnson will get destroyed at SF, persay. He's just out of position. He'll be ok, just not at his best.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top