Better Playmaker Carter or Roy?

[pegs]

<!-- / icon and title --> <!-- message -->It was brought up in the NBA General forum under the thread CBS's top 50 player rankings that some people feel Vince Carter is a better playmaker than Brandon Roy. What do you guys think?

Personally I think Carter is the better playmaker, but I'd like to hear other inputs

 

[Netsfan99]

Vince Carter is a better play-maker. Also, he played PG position in high school.

 

[Moo2K4]

Vince Carter is a better play-maker. Also, he played PG position in high school.

And this has something to do with him being a better playmaker how? Just cause you play PG doesn't make you a good playmaker.

 

[Netsfan99]

And this has something to do with him being a better playmaker how? Just cause you play PG doesn't make you a good playmaker.

R-E-L-A-X, Just because my point goes against your point in the other thread. Do not get upset.

 

[GMJ]

R-E-L-A-X, Just because my point goes against your point in the other thread. Do not get upset.

Alright, I haven't posted in the other thread. Care to explain your post?

 

[MaxaMillion711]

funny. These 2 are my favorite players. I've watched all their games. I think vince is obviously the better playmaker. In the past couple years, vince has been so good at driving and kicking and setting up teammates. So many times during the coarse of a game, whenever vince is out of the game , the offense is stagnant. When he comes back in, you really see a difference.

Now Roy is also a great playmaker, don't get me wrong. I love the guy. But since vince is way more better at offense, he draws more attention which opens up his teammates.