The issue with the numbers is that most of those guards for the most part are number 1 guys now, and only a couple of them with someone on Dame’s level. You’re kind of comparing apples and oranges.
CJ averages more FGA's than most of those guys on the list and has for the last 4 years. This season, CJ is 15th in FGA and 5 of the guys above him average less than 1 more shot a game.
Bradley Beal is 3rd in the NBA in FGA's/game at 22.0. That's 3 more shots than CJ but he averages 8 more points a game, and he's on a team with a 20-33 record. Andre Wiggins averages 0.6 less shots a game but averages 1.2 more points than CJ, and like CJ he's an option 1b. Brandon Ingram averages 1 less shot that CJ but scores 3 more points. Demar Derozan averages 3 less shots but scores 2 more points.
CJ has had 1st option FGA's for over 4 seasons; he's had a 1st option usage rate; he's had 1st option opportunity to create his own offense. It's not an apples to oranges set of comparisons.
Would you want Kemba, Kyrie, or half of those guys to play next to Dame? Cause I sure wouldn't I think we’d say the same things about them that we do about CJ.
no, I would not want Kemba or Kyrie paired with Dame but that does not mean I can't recognize both are better players that CJ. Of the first two lists of names I posted above, I'd much rather have Bradley Beal, Jimmy Butler, Khris Middleton, Victor Oladipo, Ben Simmons, Zach Lavine, Malcolm Brogdon, or Jaylen Brown than CJ. They would all be better fits and just about all are more talented, especially when defense is part of the equation.
of the rest, I'd rather have almost all more than CJ, then trade them because they' have better trade value
Problem with two guards like Dame and CJ who need the ball to be effective is there is only one ball. Weve seen WB and Harden have really good months, and really good games buts rare they’re both good at the same time, because its hard and one guy usually has to take a step back for the other.
OK...but I'm not buying it
it wasn't a problem for Curry and Durant; or Lebron & Kyrie; or Lebron & DWade; or Manu & Parker; or Thomas & Dumars. And it wasn't a problem for KG & Pierce, or Kobe & Shaq, or Kobe & Pau, or Magic & Worthy or Bird & McHale. Kawhi and PG13 are doing well too, and so are Lebron and AD
now, I'd imagine you'd return back to saying "
2 guards" even though a guard and a SF aren't really different in any significant way. For that matter, high usage bigs and a guard create a pretty similar equation in terms of ball demand
what those example show, at least to me, is having only one ball isn't the problem. NOT having two elite players is the problem. Dame's name fits with those other names, even if toward the bottom of the list. CJ has no business being considered within 7 zip-codes of those players. All those other pairings complemented each other; they brought different skills into the equation, and Thomas/Dumars was the only pairing of players close to the same size. Dame and CJ are way too redundant compared to those other duo's
all this discussion really does is highlight how logical trading CJ would be. The CJ fans could anticipate CJ going superstar on another team, while Blazer fans can anticipate a much needed change in direction