I'm gonna have to go with Chosen One on this one. NYGiants, yours is a little too dark on the bg, IMO. Also, I like the text a little better in Chosen's.Good job to both of you!Chosen One 1-0
Choosen One's sig is better because I like it's clean look and I like the font/font work better, and it just looks better overall than Giant's.Choosen One 2-0
I like Chosen One's better. Chosen One - Nice and clean. I don't think you should have put "number" maybe just the #. And the bevel doesn't look real good. I like the colors though. I think you should have made the bg a bit more visible. It's hard to see the brush marks.NYGiantsO5 - The darkness of the whole thing kills it. It's so dark you can barely see a bg. The text is bad too. It's like, smushed into the corner and the font is not to my liking.