He's definitely not a top-five talent.
No, he's not, but if you also consider defense, he's got to be top 10 or 12.
He's not LeBron, nobody is, but he plays LeBron better than anyone in the league. He did it when LeBron was in MIA ad he did it this year in the playoffs.
Even though IND got swept by CLE, every game was close. He didn't quite match LeBron's super human numbers (32.8/9.8/9.0), but his 28.0/8.8/7.3 was pretty impressive considering he was going head-to-head against the best player on the planet.
And that's what makes Paul George so valuable. No one in the world is going to out play LeBron individually, but George at least has the ability to guard LeBron (and Durant) as well as anyone, and make him work at the other end, too. It doesn't tilt the match up in your favor, but at least it makes it less lopsided.
Then you just need the rest of your roster to outplay LeBron's supporting cast de jour. Unfortunately, George didn't have that in IND, not even close. His 2nd and 3rd best teammates in that series were Jeff Teague and the ghost of Lance Stevenson past.
BNM