Religion Mid East Religious War, Now with added USA Involvement!

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Nope...You aligning me with Hitler is why I told you to fuck off!
My point was about Egypt was concerned about ruthless Hamas religious terrorist polluting their country, they are building a fucking wall.

You thought you were clever with that silly question there's been repeated mindlessly, and you didn't stop to consider that it was Hitler's same question. I didn't align you with Hitler.

You did that all on your own.
 
My pop and father law both fought against Hitler and son has fought in the mid east, so you commenting to me, that Ive aligned myself with Hitler was like a sucker punch to me. Even at 73 I won't but up with that shit. You have a history of name calling or insinuations with people her and Im not the only thats called you out on it.
 
My pop and father law both fought against Hitler and son has fought in the mid east, so you commenting to me, that Ive aligned myself with Hitler was like a sucker punch to me. Even at 73 I won't but up with that shit. You have a history of name calling or insinuations with people her and Im not the only thats called you out on it.
To be fair, the basis for that was the logic you used. Yes, the "aligning yourself with Hitler" comment was clearly intended to be inflammatory, but it also made a valid point (even if the inflammatory nature of the comment detracted from the point being made).

So, obviously you don't agree with our support Hitler or Naziism. But @AmirIcon is not wrong in saying that when Jews were trying to escape Germany before WW2 actually began, many countries (including the US) severely restricted intake of Jewish refugees if not refusing them entry outright. And Hitler's response to this was basically to say, "See, nobody else wants these Jews in their country either--clearly they're subhuman."

Unfortunately, by making the statement you made, which was:

There is a reason why Egypt has refused to open their border and take Gaza Palestinians refugee's.

... you did, in fact, invoke logic similar to that used by Hitler, without any clarifying commentary to differentiate. So rather than railing against those who pointed out the unfortunate similarity, you might consider taking a moment to clarify what you were intending to communicate. Otherwise, it will continue to look like you were suggesting that Egypt not opening their borders to innocent Palestinian refugees shows that they are not worth protecting, as though they are subhuman.
 
Hoopguru, Amiricon didn't say that you are like Hitler. To the contrary, he assumed you dislike Hitler, so you should avoid any easily corrected reasoning error, temporary to you, similar to Hitler's thinking. Get it?

There are MANY results in common between Israel's recent tactics and Germany's cruel invasion of the Soviet Union. Read the news; the civilian slaughter is there every day. And imagine the part hidden from the news--the tens of thousands of civilian men arrested, then beaten and tortured to find which can give names and locations, then killed to keep it quiet.

For example, Henry Kissinger claimed about his post-WW2 torture camp that he hadn't needed to torture because his men persuaded every German to talk without torture. The reporter was too scared to question that laughable proposition, or to ask whether the Allies' policy was to put Jews in charge of such camps due to their extra motivation.
 
Hoopguru, Amiricon didn't say that you are like Hitler. To the contrary, he assumed you dislike Hitler, so you should avoid any easily corrected reasoning error, temporary to you, similar to Hitler's thinking. Get it?

There are MANY results in common between Israel's recent tactics and Germany's cruel invasion of the Soviet Union. Read the news; the civilian slaughter is there every day. And imagine the part hidden from the news--the tens of thousands of civilian men arrested, then beaten and tortured to find which can give names and locations, then killed to keep it quiet.

For example, Henry Kissinger claimed about his post-WW2 torture camp that he hadn't needed to torture because his men persuaded every German to talk without torture. The reporter was too scared to question that laughable proposition, or to ask whether the Allies' policy was to put Jews in charge of such camps due to their extra motivation.
Saying congrats for aligning yourself with Hitler isn't inflammatory?
I compare Hitler more to Hamas, Hezbollah, and radicle clerics that want Jews dead and non existence.
 

Is there any support for this claim other than this tweet? It doesn't seem to link to any news article. It seems like if he actually made an official statement like this, it would be reported somewhere.
 
Is there any support for this claim other than this tweet? It doesn't seem to link to any news article. It seems like if he actually made an official statement like this, it would be reported somewhere.

Netanyahu has said it over and over again that he will not allow a Palestinian state, before and after October 7th. The Biden administration has said they disagree with it and that kind of talk isn't helpful.



"... It collides with the idea of sovereignty. What can you do?"

And then you can go back 8 years and see him espousing the same thing.

 
Last edited:
Netanyahu has said it over and over again that he will not allow a Palestinian state, before and after October 7th. The Biden administration has said they disagree with it and that kind of talk isn't helpful.



"... It collides with the idea of sovereignty. What can you do?"

And then you can go back 8 years and see him espousing the same thing.


Ok...but I'm asking specifically about the claim in the tweet you posted, that Eli Cohen made an official statement with the quote given.
 
Ok...but I'm asking specifically about the claim in the tweet you posted, that Eli Cohen made an official statement with the quote given.

Yes, it's reported everywhere. I was responding to the claim that it would be reported everywhere (because it was odd or a big deal) when leaders higher than him have said the same or something similar.
 
I have no problem with Israeli military going after the terrorists that invaded Israels and killed over 1000 innocent civilians and kidnapped even more but to practice genocide and kill innocent Palestinians as some eye for an eye retribution is barbaric. War used to be fought on open battlefields far from city centers...this blowing up hospitals ans schools shit has to stop and stop now. Where the fuck is the UN and does it have any fucking power anymore other than a sanction stamping office?
 
I have no problem with Israeli military going after the terrorists that invaded Israels and killed over 1000 innocent civilians and kidnapped even more but to practice genocide and kill innocent Palestinians as some eye for an eye retribution is barbaric. War used to be fought on open battlefields far from city centers...this blowing up hospitals ans schools shit has to stop and stop now. Where the fuck is the UN and does it have any fucking power anymore other than a sanction stamping office?

The whole thing stops when Israel calls the UN a bunch of Hamas supporters and the U.S. deciding to not respect international law. It's not particularly close either. It's the U.S., Israel and a few island nations and on the other side is the rest of the world.
 
Probe Documents Israeli Use of AI-Equipped 'Small Killer Drones' Against Civilians in Gaza

"Israel is intentionally using them to target Palestinian civilians in the Gaza Strip," said the Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor.

https://www.commondreams.org/news/israel-drones-gaza

A.I.'s use on a battlefield should be to ensure that the target is destroyed, without taking out civilians. A.I. should never ever be used to directly target civilians.
 
It's laughable to see Israel claim they're doing everything they can to minimize civilian death when they've literally had a policy called "mowing the lawn" for decades and they killed a Hamas guy in an apartment building with total precision and no civilian death.
 
Wonder if Israel will go after Hezbolla? In Lebanon?
 
Hezbollah are Shia and supported by Iran as is Hamas, however Hamas are Sunni. Lebanon is primarily Sunni form what I understand and Hezbollah are essentially a State within a State. So, could it be that Iran wants to disrupt any progression of the Abraham Accords and some of the Arab States would join TAA's if not for both Hamas and Hezbollah strong holds? There's an old dude like me and friend, at my Gym from Beirut and he believes that Lebanon would join The Abraham Accord if not for Hezbollah and Iran Shia influence.
 
"What I Saw Wasn't War — It Was Annihilation," Says U.S. Doctor Who Volunteered in Gaza Hospital

 
UN resolution for a cease fire supported by 13 of 15 countries.. UK abstains. US vetoes. WTF
 
He's got a point... And we could have actually made both huge successes if we had the right motives.

He's got a point but not a terribly strong one - we weren't trying to annex Iraq or Afghanistan.

Not that that makes us any better necessarily, just different.

barfo
 
He's got a point but not a terribly strong one - we weren't trying to annex Iraq or Afghanistan.

Not that that makes us any better necessarily, just different.

barfo

Exploitation is exploitation. He killed a lot less.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top