Religion Mid East Religious War, Now with added USA Involvement!

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Thank you for sharing that. That is something you'd remember. People all over are just people.

Everyone who isn't in power would happily welcome a democracy and freedom.

The question is, will the correct people be put in power? Will they allow a real true democracy?

I haven't seen much evidence of that happening historically.

I wonder, we can easily question about 'correct people' and 'true democracy'.

Lets try a different game - instead of questions - I would like to hear people's optimal solution - how you guys reckon this middle east situation should conclude and how optimaly it can be achieved assuimng what you suggest happens.
 
I dont. I know what my heart wants. And that is a regime that does not promote and calls for destruction of any other country on the globe.. making it simple..

The destruction of their governments. Not their people. A simple Google search would show that. But why obsess over rhetoric when we can obsess over action? Israel, a nation who hides their nuclear program from the rest of the world, is actually causing destruction to other nations. Let's go after those who are actually doing it, then we can focus on those and their rhetoric.
 
Evidence for temple, schools and hospitals hit in Iran please. If not available - kindly please amend your post accordingly.
To my knowledge - the IDF is targeting military / hostile administration / weapons-arms areas targets only.
No general population targeting (unlike to rockets fired from Iran that blast all over Israeli cities indesecremaenatly).
I'm not a war correspondent and we're not in possession of war propaganda or damage reports. I'm also not on trial nor in court so I can have a good faith conversation without the lawyer schtick. To your knowledge.....I will accept when you say that...I'd expect the same courtesy when I speak from "my knowledge" I'm also not excusing Iranian aggression and bombing. They have no right to bomb civilians either although I know you're fishing for a double standard here..there isn't one.
 
If Iranians are highly educated, if they want a secular democracy, it's up to them. Like the colonists. Like the French who no longer wanted kings. Like South Korea when they didn't want military dictatorship. Like the Portuguese. Like the Spaniards who got sick of Franco. Like Italians who strung up Mussolini. I am all in favor of supporting any movement towards secular democracy, starting in this country, but revolution can't be imposed from without. That's not revolution, it's occupation.
 
The destruction of their governments. Not their people. A simple Google search would show that. But why obsess over rhetoric when we can obsess over action? Israel, a nation who hides their nuclear program from the rest of the world, is actually causing destruction to other nations. Let's go after those who are actually doing it, then we can focus on those and their rhetoric.

What nation is Isreal causing destruction to? Please provide evidence..
If you mean the Palestinians - A. They are not a nation. They are a group of Arabs living as a minority in Israel that decided they want to identify as Palestinian and demand a land not theirs (that was 'stolen' from them).
B. The IRGC has nothing agains the Israeli administration. They wanted us dead when Rabin was at the Helm and want us dead when Bibi at the Helm - they want Jews / non muslims to die/convert.
So yeah - they are calling for genocide of the Israeli people. Not the country.
BTW - I have nothing against Palestinians and willing to give them 99.9% of the 1967 borders - but they just wont accept it. Beacuse they want all. They teach their kids and the world the they deserve all. (Did you see thier map? No Israel there.. )
 
You're making a huge assumption that the new regime would be better and not worse.

While what Iran has currently is not great, it is better in many ways than what other countries in the region, like Saudi Arabia and Afghanistan, have.

And France gave us money and arms, are you suggesting we do that with some sort of opposition in Iran?

Remember, we're here today because we already did a regime change in Iran of their democratically elected leader.
I get what your saying and respectfully yes, Im assuming (Thats all anyone here can do) they would be better off, because the Iranian people want it, there just outgunned and persecuted in their own land. Like Im for providing Ukraine arms and what not to take down Putin. Why is it ok for Ukraine and not Israel?
France scared of the British navy toward the end and yes supported our revolution with arms and money. Glad they did so.
My wife and I know two couples from Iran, two are citizens now. From what they say its terrible there and they cant vote people in and out like here, as they are under shira law. Both Iranian ladies are pro women and women to the mullahs supreme wacko are just property for men and at their mercy.
 
If Iranians are highly educated, if they want a secular democracy, it's up to them. Like the colonists. Like the French who no longer wanted kings. Like South Korea when they didn't want military dictatorship. Like the Portuguese. Like the Spaniards who got sick of Franco. Like Italians who strung up Mussolini. I am all in favor of supporting any movement towards secular democracy, starting in this country, but revolution can't be imposed from without. That's not revolution, it's occupation.

Do you know the difference between the Iranian people and the IRGC? Kindly wikipedia it. ASAP please..
 
I'm not a war correspondent and we're not in possession of war propaganda or damage reports. I'm also not on trial nor in court so I can have a good faith conversation without the lawyer schtick. To your knowledge.....I will accept when you say that...I'd expect the same courtesy when I speak from "my knowledge" I'm also not excusing Iranian aggression and bombing. They have no right to bomb civilians either although I know you're fishing for a double standard here..there isn't one.
Your words carry weight. I am willing to provide evidence to anything I claim and of I learn I was wrong I will stand corrected.
You conflated between two different arenas - Gaza - in which a terror organistation is hiding under schools and temples, and Iran - which is a nation country that does not.
The whole warfare theme here should be and is different
 
What nation is Isreal causing destruction to? Please provide evidence..
If you mean the Palestinians - A. They are not a nation. They are a group of Arabs living as a minority in Israel that decided they want to identify as Palestinian and demand a land not theirs (that was 'stolen' from them).
B. The IRGC has nothing agains the Israeli administration. They wanted us dead when Rabin was at the Helm and want us dead when Bibi at the Helm - they want Jews / non muslims to die/convert.
So yeah - they are calling for genocide of the Israeli people. Not the country.
BTW - I have nothing against Palestinians and willing to give them 99.9% of the 1967 borders - but they just wont accept it. Beacuse they want all. They teach their kids and the world the they deserve all. (Did you see thier map? No Israel there.. )
Chinese maps don't show Taiwan as a sovereign nation...they call it Chinese Taipei, but Gaza and the Palestinians are in their homeland, as are the Taiwanese..they have their own roots and right to be there. I don't believe in the jihadist wars at all, but not all those folks are fundamentalist religious zealots..and the water rights are not shared fairly from what I've read...I'm not qualified to speak about most geopolitical issues in the region but it's been going on since I was a kid and so far only Carter brought them close to a peaceful co-existence. Escalation of tensions is only going to amplify the blood feud.
 
Your words carry weight. I am willing to provide evidence to anything I claim and of I learn I was wrong I will stand corrected.
You conflated between two different arenas - Gaza - in which a terror organistation is hiding under schools and temples, and Iran - which is a nation country that does not.
The whole warfare theme here should be and is different
the only topic I conflated was Israel's relationship to Palestinians and Iranians...back to back bombing raids..of course they are different but militant religious nuts are in all 3 places from what I've seen. Israel had every right to defend itself from the attack last fall..they did that. Continuing to kill Palestinians as compensation went too far in my view. Nut jobs in Iran funding terror cells are also fair game in my view.
 
I hope you're safe in your home
I hope your loved ones are near
I hope you don't live in fear
I hope you're safe in your home
 
B. The IRGC has nothing agains the Israeli administration. They wanted us dead when Rabin was at the Helm and want us dead when Bibi at the Helm - they want Jews / non muslims to die/convert.

Iranian Jews have the same rights as Iranian Muslims in Iran. Unlike Arab Muslims in Israel. If the regime wants Jews to die/convert, why would Iran be the home of so many synagogues? Jews are a part of Iran's parliament with a guaranteed place at the table regardless of their minority status.

Again, a simple Google search would show this to you. I won't even waste my time with the rest of your downright demeaning rhetoric of an entire people.
 
I hope you're safe in your home
I hope your loved ones are near
I hope you don't live in fear
I hope you're safe in your home

Rich coming from a regime who created an apartheid state and are currently carrying out a genocide.
 
If anyone has some trustworthy breaking news or info about this situation I'd love to read it and become more informed. The planet has had enough bloodshed.
 
Last edited:
Everyone can disregard the propaganda that Fluffy is spewing about Iran wanting to kill Jews or convert them to Islam.

 
Do you know the difference between the Iranian people and the IRGC? Kindly wikipedia it. ASAP please..
I have appreciated your input even when I disagree because you have a perspective we do not. But I do not appreciate snide remarks. They are a poor substitute for debate.
 
If anyone has some trustworthy breaking news or info about this situation I'd love to read it and become more informed. The planet has had enough bloodshed.
Idk about breaking news, but I thought this brief synopsis was helpful in answering the question: "So why did Israel decided now was the time to take out Iran? Where they actually close to getting a nuke this time or where there other reasons?"

 
I get what your saying and respectfully yes, Im assuming (Thats all anyone here can do) they would be better off, because the Iranian people want it, there just outgunned and persecuted in their own land. Like Im for providing Ukraine arms and what not to take down Putin. Why is it ok for Ukraine and not Israel?

Russia invaded Ukraine. Israel has attacked Iran. Those are very different scenarios.
 
So we just went to war and this is all you guys have? I come here for news!
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top