What I like about Harris ( 6'2" 224) is that he looks to be a good blocker and receiver. So on passing downs, I feel good about him being in there.
As for Whittington, he struggled early in his return from injury last year, but he improved as the season progressed. And still finished the year with 6 yards per carry. I wouldn't sleep on him. He is a complete back.
As for Hughes, yeah, I expected him to be a bit more explosive. However, he may have been slow to grasp the offense, which could cause him to be indecisive on his runs.
The two true freshmen look to have a ton of potential.
Where are you seeing 6 Y/A?
Whittington had some good games against inferior competition. The only good game where he showed out was Penn State.
James -
5.4 Y/A
90.5 Y/G
1267 total yards
233 attempts
Whittington -
4.6 Y/A
38.6 Y/G
540 total yards
118 attempts
Noah's best games last season:
Oregon State - 64 yards on 7 attempts - 9.1 Y/A
Illinois - 56 yards on 7 attempts - 8.0 Y/A
Washington - 67 yards on 9 attempts - 7.4 Y/A
Penn State - 82 yards on 15 attempts - 5.5 Y/A
Noah's worst games last season:
Ohio State - 3 yards on 6 attempts - 0.5 Y/A
Wisconsin - 5 yards on 3 attempts - 1.7 Y/A
Ohio State - 7 yards on 3 attempts - 2.3 Y/A
Idaho - 33 yards on 14 attempts - 2.4 Y/A
UCLA - 21 yards on 8 attempts - 2.6 Y/A
Michigan - 36 yards on 11 attempts - 3.3 Y/A
I'm just really not comfortable handing this dude the starting spot.
Here is James against those same opponents
Ohio State - 115 yards on 23 attempts - 5.0 Y/A
Wisconsin - 121 yards on 25 attempts - 4.8 Y/A
Ohio State - 14 yards on 7 attempts - 2.0 Y/A
Idaho - 95 yards on 15 attempts - 6.3 Y/A
UCLA - 103 yards on 20 attempts - 5.2 Y/A
Michigan - 117 yards on 23 attempts - 5.1 Y/A