Despite everything thats been discussed here, this year should be the pin on the board for these two players. The Celtics team, albeit older, is hungry and ready for one last run with their young all star PG; on the flipside, Chicago finally has a legit low-post scorer (Noah was a garbage man, if anything) to run the pick-and-roll with Rose along with shooters that'll hit shots.
I'd like to see this debate between Rose and Rondo discussed after this year. It'll be interesting, and pardon my inner homer, but I can envision this year being Rose's transition year from a high-scoring PG, to a Chris Paul-meets-Dwyane Wade PG.