My (recent) criticism of Westbrook began during his "historic" streak of 4 consecutive triple-doubles. It was direct backlash against the ridiculous Russ for MVP hype that was being shoved down our throats by the media at that time, especially ESPN and that fool Mark Jackson.
My criticism at the time was simple and well founded. He was shooting too much and it was costing his team wins. During that "historic" streak he also, historically, attempted more than 30 FGA in 4 consecutive games and his team went 1-3. All the triple-doubles in the world are meaningless if your team loses because you're a ballhog more concerned about your own stats than actually winning the game.
I noted at the time how bad OKC's record was in games when Westbrook took over. At the time of his 4th consecutive triple-doubles, OKC was 2-6 in games when Westbrook attempted =>30 FGA and 2-7 in games where he scored =>38 points. The more Westbrook pads his stats, the less likely his team's chances of winning. That's not an MVP in my book.
I also noted at the time how much better OKC would be if Westbrook would use his considerable talents and physical gifts to create more easy scoring opportunities for his teammates. He has a history of freezing out Durant in the 4th quarter of playoff games and during his "historic" stretch he was flat out freezing out EVERYONE in the 4th quarter. Since that time, he hasn't had a single game of => 30 FGA or => 38 points and his team is 8 - 4 during that stretch (his high scoring game during the last 12 games was 37 points in a loss to UTA, again the more Westbrook scores, the more OKC loses). When Westbrook plays hero ball, it hurts his team, when he involves his teammates, they have a much greater chance of winning. The problem is, he plays hero ball far too often, especially when he's playing on national TV and/or in the playoffs. That's bad for OKC, but good for everyone else.
If Westbrook ever figures out the right balance of looking for his own shot vs. setting up his teammates, OKC (or whoever he's playing for) will be scary good. The question is, will his massive ego ever allow that to happen?
BNM