Rate the signature above you!

[Colonel Ronan]

Pretty self-explanatory thread. Just rate the siggy above you!

Basic Layout (Example):

Rating: 8/10

Reason for your Rating: [Here you briefly describe the pros and cons. In other words what you liked or disliked about it. What could be done to make it better/ what could be taken out to make it a bit more attractive. Please don't flame at other peoples work because some people really worked hard on what they did and just thought it would be nice to showcase it to the community.]

So without further ado let the rating begin!

 

[Hudge]

WOOHOO I start


VVVVVVVThat one down thereVVVVVVV

 

[Colonel Ronan]

6/10

Stevie and and the text aren't blended well into the sig. And the background is just strange.

 

[Wolf]

6/10

just an image of two hands joined together with guns, The arsenal supporter bar is ok. nothing bad nothing good, the background is good the badge is blended well.

 

[Colonel Ronan]

8.5/10

Very nice. The first one is flawless, background and text blend in very well, and I like how it gets gradually lighter from left to right.

I just docked points for the XboxLive tag, disrupts the flow...

 

[Evans09]

5/10

don't really see the point in that sig. just two guns joint together with some scummy arsenal text. why not do players like everyong else?

BTW rate the rooney sig.

 

[The 12th Man]

Bg is ok, Rooney is blended ok. The logo is a bit small and not blended. Not bad at all.

6/10

Rate the Gerrard sig please.

 

[echo369]

the brushes are used nicely and the logo and cut are blended in nicely and text is plain but still good.. 8/10

 

[Hutcho]

A well blended and classy sig and the text goes well. I still think it is a bit boring but overall impressive. 7/10.
Essien one please...

 

[twofivefive]

The pics are blended in well and the colour isn't bad. Text is alright but you shouldn't have the scanlines on it (only just noticed it).

 

[The 12th Man]

Well the stuart downing sig is starting to bore me because its been there forever. lol

As ive sed before the Emerton Sig is pretty good. Bg great so is the render effects. Im not a fan of the text though.

 

[twofivefive]

I'll make a new Boro one in the next couple of weeks just so you're happy lol.

The Gerrard one is good except he looks bad quality and the LFC logo should be to the right more. Vince Grella sig is good but he's too dark and saturated IMO.

 

[Hudge]

Yeah, the Stuart Downing sig is getting boring 8/10 still though.
Rate the Number 9s sig.

 

[Safc-Jim]

Good idea, but needs to use pictures of similar quality to each other, possibly some render effects and blend the images 6/10

It may help if my sig showed here

 

[Hudge]

I'll rate your avatar 5/10 I like it, it fits in with your title but it is plain

 

[twofivefive]

You need better quality photos, better blending of the cuts and the cuts should be better too. Also, try to make your own backgrounds and then just use stocks like that as an effect. Text could be better too.

 

[Wolf]

the stewart downing one is boring... been there since you came to this forum?

anyway, the brett emerton one is ok, the background is kinda boring, just lookes like youve render clouds and splattered them. text could be better.

 

[Evans09]

<div class="quote_poster">twofivefive Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">The pics are blended in well and the colour isn't bad. Text is alright but you shouldn't have the scanlines on it (only just noticed it).</div>

explain scanlines please.
rate the united sig. NOT ROONEY!

 

[Flight643]

Scanlines are simply just lines going either horizontally, Diagonally or verticle on a sig.

United sig: Text is bad, there is no need for the outer glow and bad choice of font. The box around "Glory Glory Man United" is unnecessary. The Man Utd badge is too clear. Bg needs alot of work done. The picture (looks like David May from the Champions League Final) is also unnecessary. Keep practicing.

 

[bbwMax]

Best Sig: Like the picture within the text but in all fairness i could do that on MS Word lol, still a nice Homage to the great man

 

[Hudge]

RVP Sig: I like it, I like the way it's black and white but it actually isn't if you know what I mean.

 

[bbwMax]

Hudge i like the whiteness of your sig, Simple but effective

 

[twofivefive]

Well what can I say, both of your sigs are absolutely world class and they're better than anything I've seen

I won't rate them, but I'll say that I still like the way they turned out.

 

[Hudge]

<div class="quote_poster">Max Wrote</div><div class="quote_post">Hudge i like the whiteness of your sig, Simple but effective

</div>

Yeah well that would have got 0/10 all the others would have been in negative numbers.

IMGBolt decided it would be funny to delete my sigs. Or maybe it was because they were so crap.