magnifier661
B-A-N-A-N-A-S!
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2009
- Messages
- 59,328
- Likes
- 5,588
- Points
- 113
I share GOD's frustration, saying the same thing over and over. The problem is that Christians think everyone is just like them. We sometimes hear the term "Judeo-Christian". There is no such thing as "Judeo-Christian", it's really just Christianity in evangelical dress. The two are very different. Christianity is based on acceptance of Christ as savior and son of God. If a person does not believe that Jesus is savior and son of God he/she is not a Christian, so it's impossible to be a Chrisitian atheist. I know some atheists who gift in December because it's family tradition but they clearly call themselves atheists, not Christians or Christian atheists or secular Christians. Similarly, Islam is based on submission to the will of Allah; the word Islam means "submission". So if a person does not accept Allah and Muhammed as his prophet, he/she is not a Muslim; it's impossible to be a Muslim atheist. Since Judaism is a culture and heritage as well as religion it is indeed possible to be a Jewish atheist (sometimes called secular Jew). It is not possible to be a Jewish Christian. So called Messianic Jews are actually for the most part Christian by birth who adopt some trappings of Judaism. They are no more Jews than I would be Christian if I put up a tree in December (I don't). Jews who convert are no longer Jews. It's not just American Jews; worldwide, the secular Jew is viewed by other Jews as a non observant Jew and the convert as no longer Jewish. There is also history to consider; in times past a Jew who converted was required to abandon his/her family, move from the Jewish community, which was segregated in its own neighborhood (ghetto) and renounce all practices of Judaism. Small wonder that person could not be considered a Jew.
Maybe some like magnifier just can't accept it. But can you accept that GOD and I have lived our whole lives in this culture/tradition and do know what we are talking about, even if it seems weird to you?
Atheism required no faith. Faith is accepting things for which there is no evidence. Atheism is not accepting anything for which there is no evidence. The opposite of faith.
No that's agnostic. An atheist doesn't believe in God and doesn't require evidence to support that belief. Agnostic are ones that don't believe in God because there is no evidence either way.
And I never said there is such thing as a Christian atheist. I said Christian Jew; which would apply if you believe that Judaism is of culture and heritage than a religious stance.
If you can be an atheist Jew; then one can be a Christian Jew. You can't have pieces of a belief without going all in. Sorry, you may think I'm confused, but I think it's you that is confused for thinking one can be an atheist Jew and not a Christian Jew.
