2008 GM Draft 1 Peer Evaluation Thread

Welcome to our community

Be a part of something great, join today!

Register Log in
PG:Farmar/Sessions
SG:Martin/Belinelli
SF:Granger/Ariza
PF:Villanueva/Frye
C:Bynum/Gasol
Total Salary-$29,809,496
 
Great pick in delfino.. I thought he had been picked already!!
 
C: Nick Collison / Joel Przybilla
PF: Chris Bosh / Sheldon Williams
SF: Richard Jefferson / Ricky Davis
SG: John Salmons / Thabo Sefolosha
PG: Chauncey Billups / Travis Diener

What do you guys think?
 
ZAE said:
C: Nick Collison / Joel Przybilla
PF: Chris Bosh / Sheldon Williams
SF: Richard Jefferson / Ricky Davis
SG: John Salmons / Thabo Sefolosha
PG: Chauncey Billups / Travis Diener

What do you guys think?
Click to expand...

Start Joel and you have better balance

You need some shooting off the bench
 
Ah, evaluate this.

C: Yao Ming / Spencer Hawes
PF: Rasheed Wallace / Danilo Gallinari
SF: Hedo Turkoglu
SG: Delonte West / Wilson Chandler
PG: Mike Conley / DJ Augustin

I figure when Yao's out with injuries I'd still start Sheed at the 4 and start Hawes, and have sheed play some 5 and turk play some 4. But we plan on having Yao back for the playoffs.
 
Updated Barneys

C: Eddy Curry / Etan Thomas
PF: KG / Diaw
SF: Artest / James Jones
SG: SJax / Stackhouse
PG: Stuckey / Jason Williams

Now I have a veteran PG to come off the bench. While he has his flaws, he can distribute the ball and make some shots. James Jones provides a damn solid deep threat off the bench. Etan Thomas should be fully recovered from his surgery and ready to be a nasty, pain in the ass big man and a perfect fit for this team.
 
Thoughts on my team?? I tried adding a energy and defensive squad to backup my starters, I think different combination could really be effective on the court.

C:Johan Petro/Troy Murphy
PF:Zach Randolph/Sean May
SF:Carmelo Anthony/Julian Wright
SG:Micheal Redd/Raja Bell
PG:Kirk Hinrich/Tyronn Lue
 
jtballa2o1 said:
Thoughts on my team?? I tried adding a energy and defensive squad to backup my starters, I think different combination could really be effective on the court.

C:Johan Petro/Troy Murphy
PF:Zach Randolph/Sean May
SF:Carmelo Anthony/Julian Wright
SG:Micheal Redd/Raja Bell
PG:Kirk Hinrich/Tyronn Lue
Click to expand...

lol So your PF spot will be taking around 40 shots a game considering they're both blackholes and all they do is shoot jumpers.

Check out my team so far guys:

PG: Stephon Marbury/Eric Gordon/Sergio Rodriguez
SG: Mike Miller/Martell Webster
SF: LeBron James/Shawne Williams
PF: JO/Reggie Evans
C : Chris Wilcox


I'm definitely going big with my last 2 picks but I got a playmaker/change of pace PG in Sergio Rodriguez that everyone was telling me I needed with 2 scoring PG's. But I think my team is pretty good considering what LeBron can do with a Cavs team with MUCH less talent.
 
Last edited:
PG - Rondo/Keyon Dooling
SG - Foye/Rudy Fernandez
SF - Durant/Marquis Daniels
PF - Aldridge/Boone
C - Bogut/Hibbert
 
Kid Chocolate said:
PG - Rondo/Keyon Dooling
SG - Foye/Rudy Fernandez
SF - Durant/Marquis Daniels
PF - Aldridge/Boone
C - Bogut/Hibbert
Click to expand...


In an all-NBA draft, you'll be really good in a couple of years. Too bad we have this draft every year and so really we should judge these on how they do this year, so fail.
 
Kid Chocolate said:
So age doesn't matter?
Click to expand...

Age does matter, but obviously your team is built to win in the future.


Newayz, I originaly thought we are going to vote for the team people think are most likely going to win a championship this year, but it seems like people are just building teams with different purposes and aims.
 
Age matters in the long-term. In terms of injuries and stamina, you can field a team of 30 year olds no problem.
 
Claud said:
Great pick in delfino.. I thought he had been picked already!!
Click to expand...

DELFINO went to russia or something... thats y i passed on him and PARGO... cuz they went to international teams :/
 
J_Ray said:
lol So your PF spot will be taking around 40 shots a game considering they're both blackholes and all they do is shoot jumpers.

Check out my team so far guys:

PG: Stephon Marbury/Eric Gordon/Sergio Rodriguez
SG: Mike Miller/Martell Webster
SF: LeBron James/Shawne Williams
PF: JO/Reggie Evans
C : Chris Wilcox


I'm definitely going big with my last 2 picks but I got a playmaker/change of pace PG in Sergio Rodriguez that everyone was telling me I needed with 2 scoring PG's. But I think my team is pretty good considering what LeBron can do with a Cavs team with MUCH less talent.
Click to expand...

and you got stephon marbury as a point, doesnt that say enough?? and the 2 guys that back him up one has never played a nba game in his life and the other nobody knows if he retiring yet. OOh ad you got JO at pf, and you call out my pf for being a black hole?!
 
Last edited:
jtballa2o1 said:
and you got stephon marbury as a point, doesnt that say enough?? and the 2 guys that back him up one has never played a nba game in his life and the other nobody knows if he retiring yet. OOh ad you got JO at pf, and you call out my pf for being a black hole?!
Click to expand...

Dude, don't take negative criticism personally. Not everyone has the same likes/dislikes.
 
jtballa2o1 said:
and you got stephon marbury as a point, doesnt that say enough?? and the 2 guys that back him up one has never played a nba game in his life and the other nobody knows if he retiring yet. OOh ad you got JO at pf, and you call out my pf for being a black hole?!
Click to expand...

lol Since when has Marbury not been a good point? Umm....Eric Gordon is a complete stud and will be facing back-ups, while Sergio Rodriguez is a change of pace guy that HAS played a game in his life ;) As a matter of a fact he played 67 as a rookie & 72 this last year. His games must start pass your bedtime or something sense he's a great playmaker & you obvious don't know about him. JO at least tries to play D man, May & Randolph are both matador defenders and chuck up shots on the offensive end. JO averages 2 blocks a game, and has never played with a playmaker like LeBron. O'Neal has also proven he can get a team to the playoffs unlike Randolph, so I think my PF spot is pretty solid compared to Z-Bo & May. You also have Melo & Redd, 2 other guys that will look for their shot first, while Hinrich is no playmaker, he's a shooter PG, so he won't do much if he doesn't get the ball. So there will be very little ball movement with the personnel you have.
 
J_Ray said:
lol Since when has Marbury not been a good point?
Click to expand...

He has never been a good NBA PG. He was the PG every team wanted to see on the opponent.

He put up some pretty stats, made teams worse and continually wore out his welcome pretty damn fast.
 
Marbury is pretty bad.

Sergio, on the other hand, is extremely entertaining to watch. I'll at least give him that.
 
pegs said:
Marbury is pretty bad.

Sergio, on the other hand, is extremely entertaining to watch. I'll at least give him that.
Click to expand...

However, Portland really wanted DJ Augustin because they said he was better than any of their current point guards.
 
lukewarmplay said:
However, Portland really wanted DJ Augustin because they said he was better than any of their current point guards.
Click to expand...

Portland is always draft happy, that's all :p Sergio Rodriguez is the real deal if he was on an uptempo team.
 
marbury was bad since like.. uh after his first 2 years in the league.
 
J_Ray said:
Portland is always draft happy, that's all :p Sergio Rodriguez is the real deal if he was on an uptempo team.
Click to expand...

Offensively, he's fine. Defensively, your point guards are worse than mine :eek:
 
J_Ray said:
lol Since when has Marbury not been a good point? Umm....Eric Gordon is a complete stud and will be facing back-ups, while Sergio Rodriguez is a change of pace guy that HAS played a game in his life ;) As a matter of a fact he played 67 as a rookie & 72 this last year. His games must start pass your bedtime or something sense he's a great playmaker & you obvious don't know about him. JO at least tries to play D man, May & Randolph are both matador defenders and chuck up shots on the offensive end. JO averages 2 blocks a game, and has never played with a playmaker like LeBron. O'Neal has also proven he can get a team to the playoffs unlike Randolph, so I think my PF spot is pretty solid compared to Z-Bo & May. You also have Melo & Redd, 2 other guys that will look for their shot first, while Hinrich is no playmaker, he's a shooter PG, so he won't do much if he doesn't get the ball. So there will be very little ball movement with the personnel you have.
Click to expand...

oh wow how did you know? Mommy sends me 2 bed right before Portland games, yes i have heard of sergio before i was gonna take him but then you did, and all the sudden JO is good at D because he averages 2 blocks?? big deal, and i don't get this stuff about Z Bo that he's not gonna help a winning team. WE play sports to win don't we? If hes the second or third string on a team I think he will do just fine. Ball movement might be a problem for my team but I don't see it as a huge issue I mean with different line ups my team can be very effective. And you really wanna argue Marburys that much better a play maker then Hinrich and that hes a good starting point for a team that wants to be successful in the nba??
 
Last edited:
I think we should have multiple awards. "Win now team" and "Win future team" are two suggestions. Maybe "Was Isaiah GM of this team?" too.
 
jtballa2o1 said:
oh wow how did you know? Mommy sends me 2 bed right before Portland games, yes i have heard of sergio before i was gonna take him but then you did, and all the sudden JO is good at D because he averages 2 blocks?? big deal, and i don't get this stuff about Z Bo that he's not gonna help a winning team. WE play sports to win don't we? If hes the second or third string on a team I think he will do just fine. Ball movement might be a problem for my team but I don't see it as a huge issue I mean with different line ups my team can be very effective. And you really wanna argue Marburys that much better a play maker then Hinrich and that hes a good starting point for a team that wants to be successful in the nba??
Click to expand...

I was just showing that JO is better than Z-Bo since you were attacking him. Z-Bo isn't a good team player, that's why his teams don't win, it's that simple. The problem is that he won't settle to be the second or third guy on a team cuz he's selfish, so it's gonna be a feud for shots between him, Melo, & Redd. The problem is that my playmaker is LeBron, so Marbury has a different role than Hinrich. Marbury is the compliment scorer to go with LeBron, he's the scoring PG that would compliment LeBron nice. LeBron is practically a PG, so I don't need Marbury dishing it out, just scoring.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top