With Dame, everyone said "he's playing against a bunch of DII guys". With Sharpe, it was "he's playing against a bunch of high schoolers".
At some point, you just have to assess a prospect's talent and attributes, not competition. I'm also assuming that when you say "inefficient numbers", you're talking about purely his 3pt shooting and free throw shooting because he shot 56% from the field.
Here are the reasons why Amen is ranked so highly:
height 6'5.75 (combine)
weight 214lbs (combine)
wingspan 7'0 (combine)
vertical 44" (reported)
Ability to make plays for others (like actually become be your starting PG, not just a guy who can bring the ball up the court and make the right pass)
Athleticism to play lockdown defense
I think you're going to be surprised with Amen if we draft him.
Exactly.
I don't know if kids are just getting more talented or have better training programs but you don't have 40" verticals as a lottery pick.....and not do well. At the least, you're Andrew Wiggins or Harrison Barnes....but if you can pass, defend, handle the ball, rebound, make plays, attack the rim, and provide high IQ leadereship? You're drafting a floor general who inspires the team with their presence. The fact that the twins have 40" verticals and 7' wingspans? That's incredible. And it's different than other prospects because guys like Exum, OJ Mayo, Nick Young, or Gerald Green just didn't have other skills to fall back on. Therefore, their games fell apart due to them being incredibly one dimensional.
Ignore competition for a second and use your brain and eyes here and measure the milliseconds and millimeters of space-time that you see in this footage and apply that to the spacing and speed of the NBA.
Watch the passes, the body control while in motion, where Amen positions himself both on and off ball.
I doubt he'll ever have great shooting numbers but I've felt he is a Giannis-lite or Grant Hill-lite....a Ben Simmons/Iguodala hybrid. That his brother is a 33% 3pt shooter means he has the same genetic potential to be passable from the outside, as well.
Zach Edey with a 7' 10.5" wingspan!!
Zach Edey is a unicorn, as well (so many of them in this draft!). Highest PER in modern NCAA history (since they started recording PER)...not once but TWICE in a row. At the least, he's a bigger and better Enes Kanter. Imo, due to his height and wingspan, you should take him with the hope that he may help slow Wemby down in limited spurts (a "Wemby Stopper", so to speak). he has good IQ, elite footwork, good size, and his efficiency is some of the best in college history.
At best, it's possible he becomes the Jokic in this draft where he is a quality big man taken in the second round. If Jokic is in that Sabonis (rather, what a healthy Sabonis probably would've become) tier, for example, we can say Edey's absolutely perfect ceiling would be like Yao/Ewing tier.
Personally, I'm not opposed to getting Maxey by trading Dame to the Sixers, drafting Amen, drafting Edey, and using Simons to acquire the Magic's #6 pick (Magic needing a 20ppg guard who can shoot and helping them get to the playoffs considering they were .500 for the latter portion of their season). Use the #6 on Walker - another unicorn. Use #23 on Lively (or James Nnaji, another project big man who looks like he could be a Clint Capella/Nic Claxton type player if developed).
Maxey - Sharpe - Amen - Walker - Lively /// Keon - Little - Jabari - Edey
That's a talented young core, honestly.