Natebishop3
Don't tread on me!
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2008
- Messages
- 94,167
- Likes
- 57,377
- Points
- 113
Oh for sure. There's no perfect stat out there and yes the defensive stuff has some weird stuff going on. Like I'm sure Luka's defensive rebounding numbers are contributing a lot to what we are seeing here, especially when looking at him vs Dort. These stats are always going to struggle to adjust for teammate quality and context as well.
But yeah I posted those numbers to more so illustrate what the gap is. If you don't believe in EPM's value or any other on court +/- based metric (because all of them value Bane over Simons to a pretty high degree) I get it. Like you said they all are very noisy, but I think they do a better job capturing total on court value over a large sample over what our eyes or the traditional box score can do.
Orlando has also invested a lot of picks over the last 4 drafts late in the lottery with little to show but that have hit big enough on their core 3 high picks and saw Bane as a great opportunity to make a run in the next couple years with the East in a weird 2 year flux with all the major injuries and was willing to overpay in the long term.
It's risky, but I get it much more than trading for an expiring Simons.
But not for that price. That's what you're leaving out. Nobody at any time has said that Cronin was asking for more than maybe two firsts for Ant. They gave up FOUR firsts and a swap.