He has plenty of time to change the narrative, but I'm starting to think of him as Enes Kanter. Great efficiency, but always ends with a negative +/-.
career BPM (
A box score estimate of the points per 100 possessions a player contributed above a league-average player, translated to an average team.) +
winshares/48:
Dame--> 4.9 + .177
Jrue Holiday--> 1.6 + .102
Khris Middleton--> 0.7 + .117
Devin Booker--> 0.9 + .097
SGA--> 3.2 + .137
Jamal Murray--> 0.5 + .100
Jaylen Brown--> 0.3 + .102
Jayson Tatum--> 3.3 + .148
Jimmy Butler--> 5.0 + .203
CJ--> 1.3 + .101
Brandon Ingram--> -0.1 + .078
Curry--> 6.6 + .203
Klay--> .06 + .105
De'Aaron Fox--> 0.6 + .088
Ja Morant--> 2.8 + .119
Trae Young--> 3.0 + .132
Westbrook--> 4.0 + .139
Chris Paul--> 7.1 + .235
Paul George--> 4.0 + .147
****************************************
I tried to do apples/apples by comparing back-court players, mostly; not guys who spend a lot of time in the paint
IMO, there's a lot of '
bile-induced-revisionist-history' going on in this forum about Dame right now. Kind of a jihad of minimizing the things he did well while exaggerating his flaws. No, he did not "
always ends with a negative +/-". If he did his BPM and winshare/48 numbers would NOT be superior, in many cases far superior, to most of those players on that list.
Dame was not a 2-way player; we all know that.
But looking at this list, almost every one of those players played with talent far better than what Dame played with. Jrue played with AD and Giannis; Middleton played with Giannis and Jrue; Tatum & Brown played with each other and a DPOY; Chris Paul played with AD, Harden, Westbrook, Booker. Curry played with Draymond, Klay, and Durant. Dame didn't have that luxury. And looking at that list I don't think any of those players really put a team as lacking in talent on their shoulders and carried it into the playoffs...like Dame did, several times. And almost none of those players had the dual burdens of being the #1 scoring option and the #1 playmaker and facilitator. And carrying those burdens while being one of the most double-teamed and trapped players in the league, with again, no other elite talent to draw the focus of opposing defenses. Another burden Dame had was spending a decade under one of the most incompetent GM's in the league
I get that a lot of people want to go the
'good-riddance' route when it comes to Dame. But a lot of the things being said right now are pure bullshit