on this we agree
I said so last July...that Cronin way overpaid for Ant, Nurk, & GP3. That he bid against himself and paid well over market. Now the rebuttals I got was comparisons of what Ant/Nurk were paid to other players of their caliber. But I was basing my opinion on the market last summer. Every off-season has a distinct market. Last summer, there were very few teams with the cap-space to give that 100M deal to Ant (I think 3 teams); and maybe 1 or 2 more teams that could give Nurk 70M.
But those specific teams just didn't have a need for either player. For instance, one of the teams was Indiana. I think they had about 20-25M in space. But they had Haliburton, Hield, Duarte, Nesmith, and TJ O'Connell at guard/wing and had just drafted Mathurin & Nembhard; and had Myles Turner & Isaiah Jackson at C and were in the process of trading for Daniel Theiss
IMO, market price would have been about 18M/year for Ant and 12M/year for Nurkic. And if those guys were on those contracts they'd likely have much higher trade value
GP3 was just a bad signing, all the way around